Allowing people to vote for any project they think is cool is an interesting departure from voting systems of most other Hack Club programmes (most of the time your project will battle for votes in a series of 1v1 matchups). I'm really interested to see how this plays out!
My main concern with these types of programmes is that highly technical yet difficult to demonstrate projects (think programming languages, distributed systems, OSs, CLI tools etc) tend to get disproportionately bad results in voting. People new to programmes like this could be strongly put off by their perceived bad results, and people with knowledge of how the game works will just take their projects to other Hack Club programmes. If I were running this it would have 2 separate groups of prizes: larger ones based on number of hours spent (tracked with Lapse or Hack Hour, because I strongly dislike Hackatime), and smaller ones based on number of votes. However the big flashy prizes (in this case, the Framework laptops) really do attract people – recall that Siege <https://siege.hackclub.com/> was one of Hack Club's best performing efforts despite how easy it was to sink dozens of hours into it and win nothing.
Nonetheless I see the potential and I do hope for a lot of submissions – the programme clearly distances itself from the usual Hack Club status quo ;). Good luck with it!
Why editorialize the link title with "I'm 15 and I..."?
Is there some weird SEO superstition that being a child prodigy helps HN posts
Lots of other "I'm 15" (or 16, 17, 18) HN posts are pretty obviously spam or AI slop. Im' 65, and I'm immediately suspicious and biased against such titles.
This is a perennially off topic thing that people complain about - let's not go there. When I look at https://news.ycombinator.com/submitted?id=foxmoss I see highly technical submissions that make no mention of age.
I've taken that bit out of the title now though - it's enough (and completely fine) to mention it in the text.
Allowing people to vote for any project they think is cool is an interesting departure from voting systems of most other Hack Club programmes (most of the time your project will battle for votes in a series of 1v1 matchups). I'm really interested to see how this plays out!
My main concern with these types of programmes is that highly technical yet difficult to demonstrate projects (think programming languages, distributed systems, OSs, CLI tools etc) tend to get disproportionately bad results in voting. People new to programmes like this could be strongly put off by their perceived bad results, and people with knowledge of how the game works will just take their projects to other Hack Club programmes. If I were running this it would have 2 separate groups of prizes: larger ones based on number of hours spent (tracked with Lapse or Hack Hour, because I strongly dislike Hackatime), and smaller ones based on number of votes. However the big flashy prizes (in this case, the Framework laptops) really do attract people – recall that Siege <https://siege.hackclub.com/> was one of Hack Club's best performing efforts despite how easy it was to sink dozens of hours into it and win nothing.
Nonetheless I see the potential and I do hope for a lot of submissions – the programme clearly distances itself from the usual Hack Club status quo ;). Good luck with it!
The website https://radish.hackclub.com reliably crashes my Safari so repeatedly that I simply cannot view the website whatsoever.
Interesting… do they manage to execute code when it crashes? :D
[flagged]
Please make your substantive points without being aggressive and without calling names.
https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
Why editorialize the link title with "I'm 15 and I..."?
Is there some weird SEO superstition that being a child prodigy helps HN posts
Lots of other "I'm 15" (or 16, 17, 18) HN posts are pretty obviously spam or AI slop. Im' 65, and I'm immediately suspicious and biased against such titles.
This is a perennially off topic thing that people complain about - let's not go there. When I look at https://news.ycombinator.com/submitted?id=foxmoss I see highly technical submissions that make no mention of age.
I've taken that bit out of the title now though - it's enough (and completely fine) to mention it in the text.